Where Should You Sell? Comparing the Top Resale Platforms in 2025
If you have ever asked yourself whether something should go on Poshmark or Depop, or maybe Grailed, or wait, does Vinted even exist in the US, you are not alone.
The world of online reselling is like a brunch menu: overwhelming, slightly chaotic, but full of good options. To help you figure out where to sell what, and why, here is the platform-by-platform breakdown covering commissions, audiences, shipping, and listing time.
Resale Platforms Compared (2025)
| Platform | Commission (US) | Best Products | User Experience | Ease to Ship | Time to List |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vinted | Sellers: 0% | Fast fashion, basics, high-street brands | Very easy, intuitive app | Seller handles shipping, prepaid label optional | 1 to 2 mins |
| Depop | Sellers: 0% | Y2K, streetwear, trendy vintage | Youth-oriented, social media feel | Prepaid label from buyer, easy drop-off | 2 to 3 mins |
| Poshmark | Sellers: 20% flat above $15, $2.95 under | Mid-tier to designer fashion | App can feel cluttered, lots of features | Prepaid USPS label, very streamlined | 3 to 5 mins |
| Grailed | Sellers: 9% plus 3.49% Stripe fee | Menswear, designer streetwear, sneakers | Clean but niche-focused | Flexible but more manual | 3 to 5 mins |
| eBay | Sellers: 10% plus 3% payment processing | Everything, high traffic for all categories | Clunky UI but massive reach | Flexible shipping options, seller chooses | 5 to 7 mins |
| Mercari | Sellers: 10% | Casual fashion, home goods, electronics | Simple UI, less community | Prepaid label provided | 2 to 3 mins |
| ThredUp | Sellers: varies by selling price | Mall brands, basics, family apparel | No real selling interface, they handle it | They ship it for you | Send in a bag |
| The RealReal | Sellers keep 10 to 70% of the item | Luxury and designer items | Full-service, not interactive | They ship it for you | No listing needed |
How to Choose
- Want zero seller fees and fast flips? Try Vinted.
- Got Y2K pieces and an aesthetic? That is Depop.
- Selling designer on autopilot? The RealReal is your friend.
- Just want maximum exposure for any item? eBay is the beast.
Pro Tip: Do Not Pick Just One
Cross-listing is where the magic happens. The same item can sit for two months on one marketplace and sell in four days on another, and there is no reliable way to predict which. Savie lets you list once and post across platforms in seconds.
TL;DR
- Fees, shipping, and target buyers vary wildly between platforms.
- Choose based on what you are selling and how much effort you want to put in.
- Use cross-listing to reach more buyers with less hassle.
Stop guessing where your item will sell. List it everywhere at once with Savie.
Open Savie & start listing →Don't just list it. Sell Savie.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which resale platform has the lowest seller fees?
Vinted and Depop currently charge sellers 0% commission in the US. Mercari and eBay sit around 10% plus payment processing, and Poshmark takes a flat 20% above $15.
Where should I sell designer items?
The RealReal and Grailed are strongest for luxury and designer streetwear, while Poshmark works well for mid-tier to designer fashion and accessories.
Which platform is fastest to list on?
Vinted takes 1 to 2 minutes per item and Depop and Mercari 2 to 3 minutes. eBay is the slowest at 5 to 7 minutes because it asks for the most detail.
Should I sell on more than one platform?
Yes. Cross-listing is where most sellers see the biggest jump in sales. Savie lets you create a listing once and post it across marketplaces in seconds.
Which platform has the biggest audience?
eBay has the largest reach across every category, which is why it is worth listing there even if the interface feels clunky.
More from the Savie blog
Let Savie do the selling
Savie writes your listings, cross-lists them to eBay, Poshmark and Depop, and negotiates buyer offers for you so you never sell below your minimum price.